Fall Stuffed Cookie Recipe Bundle
Whether you're building out your fall bakery menu, baking for Thanksgiving and fall gatherings, or you're just really extra and love making over-the-top seasonal cookies like us, this bundle is your jam.
Seven giant bakery-style stuffed cookies, each with its own flavor, texture, filling, and personality, so you can build an entire fall lineup without developing seven recipes from scratch.
You've got apple butter and cinnamon, brown butter and maple, pumpkin spice and espresso, peanut butter and Biscoff, pecan pie, chai, almond, warm spices, and plenty of absolutely insane stuffed centers. Together, they give you a fall and Thanksgiving lineup where every cookie actually feels different.
The Fall + Thanksgiving Collection
🍎 Apple Butter Snickerdoodle
A thick, soft, tangy cinnamon-sugar snickerdoodle with praline pecans stuffed with a from-scratch a Apple Butter Cake Ball center made with real apple butter and spiced apple cider. Basically autumn itself dressed up as a cookie, y'all.
🍁 Brown Butter Maple Cornbread
An actual sweet cornbread cookie (no but seriously...it will blow your mind that you're eating a cookie but, like, it's also cornbread) stuffed with a from-scratch Brown Butter Maple Cake Ball that tastes a little like pancakes covered in butter and maple syrup. Yes, you heard me right.
🥜 Peanut Butter Biscoff
A thick Biscoff cookie made with cookie butter and crushed Biscoff cookies, stuffed with a soft, from-scratch Peanut Butter Cake Ball and an optional creamy Biscoff core. Peanut butter and cookie butter and cake. I don't think we need to over-explain this one. 😂
🥧 Pie-Caken
Our Thanksgiving answer to the Turducken. 😂 A dessert inside a dessert inside a dessert: brown sugar oatmeal cookie → scratch Pumpkin Spice Cake → scratch Pecan Pie Core. It's stupid delicious and like eating the whole Thanksgiving dessert table in one bite.
🫖 Chai Time
A soft, buttery brown-sugar cookie rolled in crunchy chai sugar and stuffed with a dense, moist from-scratch Chai Cake Ball. Warm, fragrant, perfectly spiced, and made for the person who wants all the fall coziness without another pumpkin dessert.
🎃 Amaretto Pumpkin Pie
A dense, soft (never cakey!) pumpkin pie-inspired cookie made with real pumpkin and warm spices, rolled in pumpkin-spice sugar and stuffed with a gooey almond-amaretto filling with the most delightful little crunch. Make it boozy or use the included non-alcoholic variation for all that pumpkin-almond goodness without the alcohol.
☕ Pumpkin Spice Latte
A soft, dense pumpkin-spiced cookie made with real pumpkin and stuffed with gooey homemade Espresso Blondie Batter for a rich caramel-coffee center. Rolled in pumpkin spice sugar for a little extra warmth and crunch, it's basically your favorite fall coffee order's much more exciting cousin. You can also stuff this beauty with other amazing pumpkin pairings like cream cheese, ganache, cookie butter, etc.
A Whole Fall Menu in One Bundle
This collection was built to give you range.
Spiced. Nutty. Buttery. Gooey. Coffee-forward. Apple-y. Pumpkin-y. Maple-y. Nostalgic. A little unexpected. And absolutely not seven slightly different versions of pumpkin spice. 🫠
If you're selling fall cookies, that means your customers aren't looking at a menu where every option basically tastes the same. They can build a box with completely different flavors and textures, from familiar fall favorites like pumpkin spice latte and apple butter to flavors they probably haven't seen stuffed inside a giant cookie before.
And these recipes work especially well for seasonal production because many of the components can be batch prepped ahead of time, making it easier to tackle fall markets, preorder weekends, Thanksgiving boxes, and busy baking weeks without making every component from start to finish on bake day.
And if you're baking at home? Make a few for a fall party, bring the Pie-Caken to Thanksgiving for the sheer entertainment value, show up to a cookie exchange with something nobody else brought, or work your way through all seven because owning a bakery is absolutely not a prerequisite for making ridiculous cookies. 😋
The Amaretto Pumpkin Pie also includes a non-alcoholic option, so you can choose what works best for your customers, menu, party guests, family, or just yourself and a glorious fall cookie.
What You Get
✔️ 7 complete bakery-style stuffed cookie recipes
✔️ All from-scratch cake recipes needed for the cake-filled cookies
✔️ Specialty filling & core recipes and instructions
✔️ Non-alcoholic option for the Amaretto Pumpkin Pie
✔️ Exact weights & cup measurements
✔️ Step-by-step stuffing, shaping, assembly, and baking instructions
✔️ The Salty Baker "Tips & Tricks" guide for bakery-style cookies
✔️ Optional variations, toppings, and finishing ideas where applicable
✔️ 7 individual recipe PDFs, plus an "EZ Print" version of each so you can save that precious printer ink
Perfect For
• Fall bakery menus
• Thanksgiving cookie boxes and dessert tables
• Fall parties, gatherings, and cookie exchanges
• Cottage food bakers
• Fall markets and pop-ups
• Thanksgiving preorder weekends
• Gourmet cookie boxes
• Holiday gifting
• Home bakers who want to make something way more exciting than the standard pumpkin cookie
• Anyone who believes September through November should involve an unreasonable number of giant stuffed cookies 🍂😂
Digital Download Only
This bundle includes seven digital recipe PDFs. No physical cookies or products will be shipped. Files are delivered digitally after purchase. Redistribution or resale of recipes is not permitted.