Christmas Stuffed Cookie Recipe Bundle
Whether you're building out your holiday bakery menu, baking for Christmas parties and cookie boxes, or you just really love making over-the-top Christmas cookies, this bundle gives you seven completely different bakery-style stuffed cookies that are made to stand out.
Seven giant bakery-style stuffed cookies, each with its own flavor, texture, filling, and personality, so you can build an entire holiday lineup without developing seven recipes from scratch.
You've got rich chocolate and peanut butter, pistachio, cherry and almond, espresso and vanilla bean, hot cocoa and marshmallow, gingerbread, warm holiday spices, and plenty of absolutely insane stuffed centers. Together, they give you a Christmas menu where every cookie actually feels different.
The Christmas Collection
🍫 Chocolate Peanut Butter Buckeye
A thick, deeply chocolate cookie loaded with chocolate chips and stuffed with a soft scratch-made Buckeye peanut butter filling, with another little chocolate center hidden inside because apparently chocolate and peanut butter and more chocolate was necessary. Obviously.
🍒 Cherry Almond
A tender almond sugar cookie with a crunchy sugar crust, dried cherries, and sliced almonds around soft, from-scratch Cherry Cake with an optional bright cherry preserve center.
☕ Iced Sugar Cookie Latte
A vanilla bean Christmas sprinkle sugar cookie stuffed with a from-scratch Espresso Cake Ball for all the cozy holiday coffee-shop vibes...rounding it all out with a creamy salted Vanilla Bean Fudge Core tucked into the middle to represent that famous iced coffee cold foam.
🔥 Gingerbread S'mores
An incredibly buttery graham cracker cookie loaded with chocolate and marshmallow, stuffed with from-scratch molasses Gingerbread Cake and finished with gooey toasted marshmallow. Say less.
💚 Hole in One Pistachio
One of our most-requested bakery flavors: a soft brown-sugar cookie loaded with pistachios and creamy chips, stuffed with an ultra-moist Pistachio Cake Ball. Salty, sweet, nutty, buttery, and SO so stinking good.
☕ Tipsy Hot Cocoa
A thick, rich cocoa cookie with a gooey marshmallow center that tastes like hot chocolate in cookie form. Make it "tipsy" for a warm boozy hot-cocoa flavor or use the included non-alcoholic variation for a classic Hot Cocoa Cookie. This recipe is adaptable to whatever alcohol or flavor you want to add to it...peppermint, Irish cream...the sky is the limit!
🎅 Gingerbread Man Off Duty
A giant, tender snickerdoodle rolled in gingerbread sugar and stuffed with a dense, velvety Gingerbread Rum Ball. Make it boozy or use the included non-alcoholic substitutions for all the gingerbread goodness without the alcohol.
A Whole Christmas Menu in One Bundle
This collection was built to give you range.
Chocolatey. Nutty. Fruity. Spiced. Gooey. Buttery. Coffee-forward. Nostalgic. Colorful. All we're missing is the kitchen sink haha.
If you're selling Christmas cookies, that means your customers aren't looking at seven cookies that basically taste like variations of the same thing. They can build a box with completely different flavors and textures, which gives them a pretty good reason to order more than one. 😉
And these recipes work especially well for holiday production because many of the components can be batch prepped ahead of time, making it easier to tackle markets, preorder weekends, cookie boxes, and busy December baking without making every component from start to finish on bake day.
Both boozy recipes also include non-alcoholic options, so you can choose what works best for your customers, menu, party guests, or just yourself and a glorious cookie. 😋
What You Get
✔️ 7 complete bakery-style stuffed cookie recipes
✔️ All from-scratch cake recipes needed for the cake-filled cookies
✔️ Specialty filling & core recipes and instructions
✔️ Alcoholic + non-alcoholic options for Tipsy Hot Cocoa and Gingerbread Man Off Duty
✔️ Exact weights & cup measurements
✔️ Step-by-step stuffing, shaping, assembly, and baking instructions
✔️ The Salty Baker "Tips & Tricks" guide for bakery-style cookies
✔️ Optional variations, toppings, and finishing ideas where applicable
✔️ 7 individual recipe PDFs, plus an EZ Print version of each so you can save that precious printer ink
Perfect For
• Christmas bakery menus
• Christmas cookie exchanges and parties
• Cottage food bakers
• Gourmet cookie boxes
• Holiday gifting and dessert tables
• Holiday markets and pop-ups
• Christmas preorder weekends
• Home bakers who want to make something way more exciting than the standard Christmas cookie tray
• Anyone who would like December to involve an unreasonable number of giant stuffed cookies 🎄😂
Digital Download Only
This bundle includes seven digital recipe PDFs. No physical cookies or products will be shipped. Files are delivered digitally after purchase. Redistribution or resale of recipes is not permitted.